Halos Heaven: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: RSL Soapbox for Real Salt Lake Fans!

The 100 Greatest Angels: #12 Rod Carew

#12 Rod Carew, 1B

Career Stats

When it comes to Angels 1Bmen, Wally Joyner has only one rival in Angel lore, and it is not gold-glover Darin Erstad.

First Baseman Rod Carew was an integral piece of the Angels first golden era. One, it could be argued, that Waly Joyner inherited after Carew and company had done the heavy lifting.

When the Angels traded for Carew in February of 1979, it was classic Autry saddlebagging - grab the player, grab the headline, cut the check, sell the tickets. One thing lost in the history of the franchise is the role that pre-cable over-the-air subscription television channel ON-TV played in the team's fortunes. ON-TV broadcast Dodger and Angel home games to its subscribers - at the time this was a radical concept - conventional wisdom asserted that ticket sales suffered from too many telecasts. So ON-TV charged viewers for premium sports games and films just recently departing theaters (this was back when only rich people had VCRs and there were no movies to be rented anyway) and in turn, the Angels and Dodgers grew richer. This revenue stream coincided nicely with the Angels picking up Rod Carew in a trade with the Minnesota Twins for some promising prospects.

By 1986, ON-TV had merged with Selec-TV, was focused much more on the Kings and Lakers as video rental stores were populating the earth, and Rod Carew had retired. But after two division championships and finishing on the high note of a 90-win 1985 campaign that concluded days after his 40th birthday, Rodney Cline Carew knew Cooperstown was his next stop and he made a classy, gracious exit.

While his name among the annual league-leader board lists noticeably falls off coincident with his arrival in Anaheim, the buzz he created among the Angel faithful and the victories to which he contributed - not needing to carry a team alone when Baylor and Reggie were along for the ride - it all makes for a great Angel legacy.

Statistically, Carew was an All-Time Angel leader in some of the bigger categories:
Batting Average: 1st (.314)
On Base %: 1st (.393)
Hits: 8th  (968), 9 more than Joyner in 204 fewer Plate Apperances.
With a 6th place Angel Career OPS+ of 119, Carew sits tied with Jim Edmonds and Troy Glaus, and just behind Joyner's 120.

Carew's consistency at the plate and in the field during the ON-TV years built up and solidified the Angels fan base. It is neck and neck with Wally until Carew's one considers the built-in appeal of the veteran All-Star personifying your team. Rod Carew was the gold standard - the Angels could not be questioned with the certainty of excellence his presence on the roster provided.

And then there is the little matter of the voting for the Top 40 being skewed just a bit with yeswecan selecting Carew as his #2 All-time Angel. Quite the compliment! Sorry, Wally, that's democracy.

0 recs  |  Comment 14 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

yeswecan't
If by Number 2, you meant "number two among Angels' first basemen all time, if that," then maybe....

by mattwelch on Feb 18, 2006 12:05 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

hard to argue those numbers...
Carew was a stud!!  This may be blasphemy on this site but I don't think Wally could carry Rodney's jock.

by thewebb on Feb 18, 2006 8:56 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

By Win Shares
Career Win Shares in an Angels uni:

Player           WS
-----------------------------
Wally Joyner   119.0
Rod Carew      102.8

It's pretty close, but Joyner was the better player when he was with the Angels. Joyner had better peak years, too:


     Rod Carew
+--------+--------+
| season | tot_ws |
+--------+--------+
|   1979 |   16.4 |
|   1980 |   20.3 |
|   1981 |   12.0 |
|   1982 |   16.8 |
|   1983 |   16.2 |
|   1984 |    9.0 |
|   1985 |   12.1 |
+--------+--------+


    Wally Joyner
+--------+--------+
| season | tot_ws |
+--------+--------+
|   1986 |   21.0 |
|   1987 |   22.5 |
|   1988 |   22.2 |
|   1989 |   19.3 |
|   1990 |    8.9 |
|   1991 |   25.1 |
|   2001 |    2.0 |
+--------+--------+

The early bird gets the worm, but the second mouse gets the cheese.

by scareduck on Feb 18, 2006 4:08 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

Erratum
Joyner's career numbers should actually be 121 win shares with the Angels.
The early bird gets the worm, but the second mouse gets the cheese.

by scareduck on Feb 18, 2006 4:09 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

I didn't know
bronze came in colors
Donnie Moore died an Angel

by eyespy on Feb 18, 2006 9:23 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

Overall
Obviously, Carew was a greater player than Wally.  But as a Halo only, I just don't see it.
The worst thing is the day you realize you want to win more than the players do. -Gene Mauch

by Chronicles on Feb 18, 2006 4:42 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

agreed....
As a Halo only they were comparable.  Putting Carew's career up against Wally's there is no argument.  Sorry, I misunderstood the context.

by thewebb on Feb 19, 2006 7:56 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

Charity Empressa
Is an Ambient/Drone Project i have put out a few times.  

On the first record, i had song called "Carew".

He is one of my favorites.

Halo Country

by cupie on Feb 19, 2006 10:45 AM PST reply actions   0 recs

#2 of all time
i was 9 years old when my dad took me to a game that went into the 16th inning. it was such a privilege to be up that late, i could hardly stand it.

in the bottom of the 16th, carew slung his bat around in that casual, loping manner, and somehow managed to hit a line drive that barely cleared the right-field wall. game over.

the place went berserk. and i became an angel fan for life.

voting him #2 probably isn't the most accurate, statistically, but when i think of the Greatest Angels, i think of 2 people first: Nolan and Carew.

oh yeah, is wally joyner in the HOF?

by yeswecan on Feb 19, 2006 5:53 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

wow
You were so nice and genuine there and then OUCH!

(kinda like the way you play poker)

by Rev Halofan on Feb 19, 2006 6:44 PM PST up reply actions   0 recs

re: Carew
I knew this was coming and would be the selection that would most bug me.
Carew was one moody bastard who saw a racist behind every tree.

The guy belongs in the hall of fame.  He hit the ball hard and where the opposition wasn't.  He must have a high BABIP.  His home runs were line drives which just happened not to get stopped by the wall.  I was there for his 3,000 hit where he gave a tip of the hat, but no words.  Looking at the stats, I wish we had someone with his OBP now.  But other contemporary Angels were more popular and he didn't have the statistics comparable to the first baseman of his time.

The Hall of Fame plaque contains a bit more information than the write-up, so maybe everybody just wanted to avoid the following.  I used to give him the benefit of the doubt considering his snarl towards kids asking for autographs as a sign of cultural or language differences.  But he whined immediately upon joining the Angels about how he should be the 2B.   It was a running joke with the Angel announcers whether Rod was talking to them this week or not.  And he was the only player that I remember Gene Autry complaining about his whining stating, "We celebrated his retirement, had a day for his 3,000 hit, and gave him [numerous team awards.]  What more could we have done for him?"

It would be one thing, if his club-house behavior was to push the other players like Erstad, Edmonds, or Percival.  But it is faint praise to say that Carew was not as disruptive as Alex Johnson.

by Barca on Feb 21, 2006 1:18 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

re: Firstbaseman
"When it comes to Angels 1Bmen, Wally Joyner has only one rival in Angel lore" - Carew

I am sure that statistically Carew and Joyner are heads and shoulders ahead of other 1Bs offensively particularly with their longevity.  But Angel faithful have room in their hearts to remember Don Mincher, Jim Spencer, Bob Oliver, and JT Snow.  Heck, Mo Vaughn probably has better stats than those guys and is easily the worst fielder.

 

by Barca on Feb 21, 2006 1:28 PM PST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Halos Heaven is the world's 12th Most Important Baseball Blog, according to Sports Media Challenge.
Start posting about the Angels »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Ph_444440_small
HH Quick Tip: "Resign" vs. "Re-sign"
Angels-stadium-angels-helmet_small
Mount Halos (instead of Mount Rushmore)
Small
Vlad to the Rangers?

Recent FanPosts

Angelsbathroom_small
Kendry Morales & Historical Angels MVP Votes
Img_0792_small
An Emotional Plea for John Lackey's Return
Small
Should the Angels make a play for Josh Johnson?
Small
Aroldis Chapman & Kendry Morales now have the same agent
Small
Juan Rivera for Curtis Granderson?
Adenhart2_medium_small
Read My Lips, No New Free-Agents!!!
Keepcalm3_small
Alternative Angels Awards
Small
Shore up the Pen
Guerrero2_small
My 2010 Opening Day Prediction

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SPONSORS