* C. Joe Mauer * 1B. Mark Teixeira * 2B. Robinson Cano * 3B. Evan Longoria * SS. Derek Jeter * OF: Franklin Gutierrez * OF: Ichiro Suzuki * OF: Carl Crawford * Pitcher: Mark Buehrle Of course Jeter wins again. I think Jeter could DH and still win a GG. There are a couple other odd choices, but I think Jeter was the worst.