Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Ryder Hesjedal Wins Giro d'Italia

Scioscia's Shrink

The jury is still out about Mike Scioscia’s current value. Many are willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, blaming Reagins for our recent struggles. Others want Scioscia’s head on a platter. Most of us are still puzzling it out. Is he a good manager or not? I recently came upon a thread of posts, enthusiastically advocating for hiring Francona and making Sosh the General Manager. This, of course, is a profoundly stupid idea to anyone who knows anything about Sosh’s strengths and weaknesses. For what it’s worth, I think Scioscia’s a potentially great manager, with one big problem buried, like a malignant tumor, deep inside.  

Star-divide

What we’ve got is an above-average manager in terms of player motivation and on-field tactics. Sure, he’s had some trouble managing the bullpen lately, but he who is without sin cast the first stone. Everyone screws this up at some point; he has made mistakes, but I blame a lack of talent over bad managerial moves. We just don’t have a real closer yet. Scioscia’s problem, it seems to me, is psychological. He can't choose or manage catchers. At first thought this seems extraordinary, certainly ironic. But a little coffee house psychology may explain a lot.

Who does Scioscia really want catching for the Angels? He wants himself behind the plate, the young man he no longer is but still dreams of being. Because this is impossible in the light of day, Scioscia’s found the next best thing, a malleable player who he can control, utterly, and mold into a new version of his old self.

Strong players have their own unique skills. Napoli was never going to be Sciocia’s puppet. He’s too good. Conger’s obviously no miniature Sciocia either, try as he may. So Mathis it is. Mathis, who is smart enough to recognize that he’s not particularly good at any aspect of the game, will do anything, everything he’s asked, in his desperation to stick around the big leagues for as long as he can. So, until Scioscia either wakes up or finds another clone of himself, Mathis is the one.

And so the battle goes, between the rational Scioscia--who surely recognizes that he’s playing a sub-average catcher almost every day, damaging this team he obviously loves--and the dream-state Scioscia, clutching desperately to the fantasy that it is really him behind the plate, calling games, framing pitches, playing that excellent Sciocia D of those glory days of Dodger blue.

Will the recent example of Mike Napoli's breathtaking success in Texas finally get through the Sosh? Does he have, or will he  find, the fearless self awareness to look into himself and find the festering wound, that stubborn child hiding in his subconscious, undermining his otherwise excellent managerial skills? 

Poll
What kind of man is our manager?
Will Scioscia bench Mathis next season and begin to allow his young catchers to develop their own baseball identities, and thus reach their potential?
33 votes
Or will Angels catching remain a crippling weakness, next season and beyond, keeping us always on the edge of greatness but never great?
32 votes

65 votes | Poll has closed

This Fan-Post is authored by an independent fan. Tell us what you think and how you feel.

Comment 9 comments  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Mathis is the one as long as our ace, Jered Weaver, prefers him as his personal catcher

and has been quoted as saying he is one of the best defensive catchers in baseball. So there you go, analyze that Shrinky.

Napoli's 27th, 28th, 29th and 30th homers of the year (four more than Jeff Mathis' career total) rained down on Angel Stadium like knives from the ceiling.

by 44FAN on Oct 1, 2011 10:00 AM PDT reply actions  

I thought Scioscia's shrink was Mario Batali?

"I'm Tony Reagins. People seem to like me because I am polite and I am rarely late. I like to eat ice cream and I really enjoy a nice pair of slacks. Years later, a doctor will tell me that I have an I.Q. of 48 and am what some people call mentally retarded."

by PieceOfAase on Oct 1, 2011 10:01 AM PDT reply actions  

Did Mike Scioscia "Lose the team" after his "Boston Massacre"....the suicidal suicide sqeeze?

Tito Francona,Jr., Manny Delcarmon, the Angles players and North America knew he wanted to squeeze. The same group is hip to his insistance on the vaunted “Contact Play” as well as ill timed sacrifices. I agree with your thoughtful analysis of the catching situation. Tony Reagins “took one for the team.” He didn’t have the juice to take Vernon’s 82 million. Kazmir was an organizational cost saving altenative to signing Lackey, (they thought Butcher could “coach him up”)….Baseball is making wholesale fireings and “reassignments”….should’nt Hatchcer and Butcher be re-evaluated?

by angelfan1954 on Oct 1, 2011 12:33 PM PDT reply actions  

Scioscia wants a completely submissive catcher

Scioscia wants submissive catchers. Scioscia wants to call ALL the shots. They got rid of the Molina brothers and Napoli, all excellent catchers who were assertive leaders. I believe it is more of a control issue.

by Rivcuban on Oct 1, 2011 1:26 PM PDT reply actions  

Perhaps you want Terry Collins back?

The only thing that bothers me with Fat Mike is his Mathis obsession. A good GM would have DFA’d him.

Unlike this cat, my love for the LAA will never die.

by NathanielS on Oct 3, 2011 8:01 AM PDT reply actions  

10 years is enough

10 years is a long time to manage the same team. I will be the first that says there is 95 percent of Angel fans who like Mike. Some think he is a God. But, I on the other hand think he is a good manager but its time to leave. He needs to be held responsible for the Angels not making the playoffs.

1. The way the team played in Sept and the last two weeks, especially with Boston saying here Angels we are going to tank for you.

2. The team was a flat out embarrassment running the bases this year. This is on the manager, he needs to be held accountable. The team never improved but continued to run them selfs out of innings late in the season, especially in Toronto. It was just not one player, there were several players who be called out on the bases such as getting doubled off on a pop fly. Can he fire a base coach too?

3. The over managing of his pitching staff, I wish there was a stat that had all the Angels games this year where the team had a two or three run lead late and the starter was pitching well only to not be able to go out and start the 7th or 8th or taken out in the middle of the 8th only to see the pen blow it. I would guess over ten games which would of gave us a play off berth. I remember the loss on a Sunday at Dodger Stadium, where the starter should of went the distance I believe the Wells hit a two run homerun to go up 2-1. Mike took out the starter and and Walden with about 45 seconds to warm up blew the game.

How many times would you see a starter up 3-1 and has not giving up a run since the 2nd inning, but because we have a match up problem in the top of the 8th or the pitcher is a 100 pitches Mike would pull him?

Finally, if you google Angels Baseball Rumors. You will see what I knew and some of you knew, Mike was basically the GM of the team, or lets say shared duties and had way too much in put . This team lacked power, trading Napoli was just as much Mike as it was Reagins. The Angels had two catchers this year where National League pitchers had a higher batting average.

Mike, is better suited as a National League manager, that is where he needs to be. Fans , wake up, the Angels are not going to beat Texas, NY, Boston or Detroit to get to a World Series, with 3 infielders all 5 foot 8 or 9 with no lack of power. 10 years from the last World Series is too long, especially when the Angels only played in a 4 team division.

Mike will stay, but hopefully a strong GM comes in and tells Mike to just manage the team and not play GM. Maybe he will resign and the Angels can look more like an American League team this year. The Angels scored a total of 667 runs this year, lowest run total since 1994. Its a shame Tony and Mike didnt realize that if the Angels kept Napoli and added some 3rd base power, we had a great 1-2 punch in a short play off series with Weaver and Haren.

by ca1forniaangels on Oct 4, 2011 10:09 AM PDT reply actions  

For Mike Fans

for those who say will Mike won a World Series for us, or would you like Terry Collins back? Then your settling, if you cant see that this was not one of Mike’s finest managerial jobs then your too much of a fan and a homer.

As I read on the internet this morning, one GM added Mike was basically the GM. I read a couple of days ago, another GM does not want to play second fiddle to Mike.

You want Mike back as manager if;

1. If you enjoy watching players making the same base running blunders over and over through the year on the base paths, with no improvement.

2. Seeing Callapso hit 4th in a game or Maicer, basically seeing 4 or 5 single hitters that are 5 foot 8 in the line up.

3. Not knowing who in the heck is in the line up the next day.

4. Having your lead off hitter hit 2 home runs and score 5 runs but the next day he is hitting 9th because of match ups, some times you can just over think too much .

5. In a race to get a play off spot and Aberu goes 0-5 and strikes out 4 times but he starts the next night in Toronto.

6. Seeing a starting pitcher throw a gem and seeing the other team having trouble getting runner on base or scoring and the starter is pulled late only to see the bull pen blow it.

Iv been criticized here basically every time I have a post, but one thing that is consistent is I have wanted Mike gone for the last three years,

by ca1forniaangels on Oct 4, 2011 10:21 AM PDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Halos Heaven is the Number #1 Angels Fan Blog according to QUANTCAST. Our Angels Fan Site is YOUR Angels Fan Community!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Morales-mainx-large_small
Albert Pujols – A Man of Faith
Small
Summation of the Angels 2012 season so far
Sinatra2_small
Sign the petition to end "Buttercup"

Recent FanPosts

Kendry_morales_small
The Most Frightening Word in Baseball: "Rebuilding"
Avatar_small
By The Numbers: MLB Starting Pitchers
Small
Angel Games Boring?
Angelmike_small
Terry Smith. You make the call.
Nick_small
Are the Angels the anti-Rangers?
Wrigley_field_small
A Serious top 5 of why Pujols is below the Mathis line.
Angelmike_small
The Top Ten Reasons Albert Pujols is hitting below 200

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Yahoo_full_count

Leaders of the Free World

4323_1105939621665_1622022962_290465_5300842_n_small Rev Halofan

Mostinterstingman_small cupie

Tn96_small WiHaloFan

Whammy10_small blast21dave

Fearless Crew

N1222371_8709_small scottnak

Halos2_small Stirrups

Anarangels_small Mayheminthehood

Cant-tell-if-trolling-or-just-very-stupid_small linkbruin

Avatar_small rghan

Alternate-club-logo-no-highlight1_small RexTookMyStash

Celebrity Chefs

306996053509_0_0_small PhiSlamma

Angelsbathroom_small mattwelch

Angels_ywc_album_small yeswecan

34_adenhart_small RallyMonkey5

Userpic-105-100x100_small Suboptimal

The_prior_art_cover_small Turks Teeth