Mathis throws to wrong base. Thanks to Nocturne for posting this in the Post Game Thread, as I had not been able to watch it during the game. It is so unbelievable on multiple levels, it deserves to be posted. Never this situation before. The confusion on Haren. The confusion on the batter. On first glance it appears Mathis body movements that he is actually throwing towards second but somehow the ball went to first. I had to rewatch it multiple times just to see the ball go towards first. Weren't his teammates screaming to him "Runner's going, hes going, he's going"? Also props to Trumbo for catching the ball. He could not have been expecting it. So what is the consensus now, band together and nominate Mathis for ASG?