clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Angels 2011 draft retrospective: Reagins' last ride gave us Cron and not much else

New, 19 comments
Robert Hanashiro-USA TODAY Sports
With the 2016 MLB Draft rapidly approaching, we're starting to really ramp up the draft coverage here at Halos Heaven. Jessica has been taking some looks at the organizational depth at various positions, and Turks Teeth has already unleashed the first iteration of his popular consensus rankings. So basically, we're covering the big picture stuff here before we get into June, narrow our focus and get down to the draft nitty gritty.

I figured it'd be as good of a time as any to look back at the past five years or so of draft wins and losses. If you're an Angels fan and/or a regular reader here at Halos Heaven, then you'll know that we'll be seeing more losses than wins, when it comes to poring over draft picks of yesteryear.

2011 was the last ride of Tony Reagins in the GM chair, and Ric Wilson's first year as head of scouting for the Halos. Both gentleman, looking back retrospectively, failed in similar ways when it came to discovering or developing talent; the Angels like their ho-hum college arms and shy away from a lot of the other tastier picks that other clubs picked up on.

The Angels had the 17th pick in the first round, and with it they chose a guy we've all come to know and love/hate: C.J. Cron. Cron was coming out of the University of Utah, and sites like Baseball America, as well as other pro scouts, had him as an intriguing 1B option. He was touted as one of the better "pure power" hitters in the entire draft, and with that sort of outlook, fans like myself thought we had a slugger on our hands.

Well...not so much. Cron has gotten himself plenty of playing time over the past few years, but has unfortunately shown a propensity for some nasty cold streaks. The dude mashes in AAA and spring training, but we're never quite sure what Cron we're going to get once it comes to the Angels' regular season.

In 113 games last year, his most playing time to date, he was good for 0.5 WAR and that slugging we hung our hopes on came in unpredictable spurts. Still, he's probably got a 1B gig here in Anaheim for the foreseeable future, seeing as how they are moving Albert Pujols into a more regular DH role, and they aren't really brimming with other 1B options in the minors.

Did the Halos whiff big time? Ehhh...kinda, sorta, but not by THAT much. The best names in the first round were guys already off the board(Gerrit Cole, Jose Fernandez, Francisco Lindor, Anthony Rendon) but right after the Angels selected Cron, the A's took Sonny Gray, and a few picks later, the Cards got Kolten Wong. Would you rather have one of those two guys, or Cron? I will take one of the former, thank you.

The rest of the draft was pretty uneventful, in a totally Angels sorta way. College players as far as the eye could see, with a few prep, high-upside guys thrown in here and there, for good measure. In big league playing time terms, this draft is pretty close to useless. There is Cron, and then there is 31st round pick Jett Bandy, and beyond that there isn't really anybody from that group that's gotten to the big league club and helped out in any meaningful way. To add insult to injury, 4th rounder Mike Clevinger was traded away by Jerry Dipoto(for Vinnie Pestano!!!) and is now up with the Indians and doing well. Ouch.

Take a long look...drink it in. This is how weak farm systems begin. But trust me...it gets worse. 2011 was just the beginning.

Rnd OvPck Name Pos Drafted Out of
1 17 C.J. Cron (minors) 1B University of Utah (Salt Lake City, UT)
3 104 Nick Maronde (minors) LHP University of Florida (Gainesville, FL)
4 135 Mike Clevinger (minors) RHP Seminole Community College (Sanford, FL)
5 165 Andrew Ray (minors) LF Northeast Texas Community College (Mount Pleasant, TX)
6 195 Austin Wood (minors) RHP University of Southern California (Los Angeles, CA)
7 225 Abel Baker (minors) C Grayson County College (Denison, TX)
8 255 Logan Odom (minors) RHP University of Southern California (Los Angeles, CA)
9 285 Nick Mutz (minors) RHP
10 315 Drew Martinez (minors) CF University of Memphis (Memphis, TN)
11 345 Garrett Baker (minors) LHP Liberty University (Lynchburg, VA)
12 375 Joey Krehbiel (minors) 3B Seminole HS (Seminole, FL)
13 405 Jackson Whitley (minors) 1B North Augusta HS (North Augusta, SC)
14 435 Wayne Taylor (minors) C Memorial HS (Houston, TX)
15 465 Dominic Jose (minors) CF Boca Raton Community HS (Boca Raton, FL)
16 495 Frazier Hall (minors) 1B Southern University and A&M College (Baton Rouge, LA)
17 525 Hunter Lockwood (minors) C L. D. Bell HS (Hurst, TX)
18 555 Trevor Hairgrove (minors) SS University of California, Riverside (Riverside, CA)
19 585 Ryan Crowley (minors) LHP Northwest Florida State College (Niceville, FL)
20 615 Juan Carlin (minors) LHP University of South Florida (Tampa, FL)
21 645 Shane Riedie (minors) RHP University of Tampa (Tampa, FL)
22 675 Brennan Gowens (minors) OF California State University Fresno (Fresno, CA)
23 705 Zach Borenstein (minors) RF Eastern Illinois University (Charleston, IL)
24 735 Jarrod Parks (minors) 3B Mississippi State University (Mississippi State, MS)
25 765 Joshua Alvarado (minors) RHP GateWay Community College (Phoenix, AZ)
26 795 John Gianis (minors) CF North Carolina State University (Raleigh, NC)
27 825 Brian Hernandez (minors) 3B University of California, Irvine (Irvine, CA)
28 855 Daniel Vargas-Vila (minors) RHP University of West Florida (Pensacola, FL)
29 885 Greg Larson (minors) RHP University of Florida (Gainesville, FL)
30 915 Mike Papi (minors) RF Tunkhannock Area HS (Tunkhannock, PA)
31 945 Jett Bandy (minors) C University of Arizona (Tucson, AZ)
32 975 John Leonard (minors) RHP Boston College (Chestnut Hill, MA)
33 1005 Erik Forgione (minors) SS W. F. West HS (Chehalis, WA)
34 1035 Andy Workman (minors) LF Arizona State University (Tempe, AZ)
35 1065 Stephen Tromblee (minors) LHP Lamar University (Beaumont, TX)
36 1095 Brandon Brewer (minors) SS University of West Florida (Pensacola, FL)
37 1125 Brandon Efferson (minors) RHP Southeastern Louisiana University (Hammond, LA)
38 1155 Frank DeJiulio (minors) RHP University of Tampa (Tampa, FL)
39 1185 Chris Giovinazzo (minors) LF University of California, Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA)
40 1215 Joe Church (minors) RHP Marshall University (Huntington, WV)
41 1245 Brandon McNelis (minors) RHP Northeastern University (Boston, MA)
42 1275 Jason Nappi (minors) 3B Harding University (Searcy, AR)
43 1305 Kyle Mahoney (minors) C High Point University (High Point, NC)
44 1335 Landis Ware (minors) 2B Baylor University (Waco, TX)
45 1365 Matt Scioscia (minors) C University of Notre Dame (South Bend, IN)
46 1395 Michael Johnson (minors) LHP Hillsborough Community College (Tampa, FL)
47 1425 Brandon Lodge (minors) RHP University of California, Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA)
48 1455 Ricky Pacione (minors) C Marist College (Poughkeepsie, NY)
49 1485 Matt Vedo (minors) RHP University of California, Santa Barbara (Santa Barbara, CA)
50 1515 Trent Garrison (minors) C California State University Fresno (Fresno, CA)
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/25/2016.