I chose to only rank the guys who were on the roster at the end of the season. This excludes players like Cameron Maybin and Danny Espinoza who finished the season elsewhere. These rankings are also based on the entire season, and not just the past week / recent performances.
Albert Pujols, to no surprise, sits on the bottom of this list in terms of regular every day players and CJ Cron had the highest ranking for guys who didn’t play on a regular basis throughout the year (aside from Upton and Phillips who joined the team in September).
These rankings were compiled with the help of MLB stats, FanGraphs, misc. data, personal opinion, scribblings on Cam Bedrosian’s Five Guys wrappers, and some fairy dust I found hidden in Matt Shoemaker’s beard.